Conspiracy Theorists Are Asking The Same Question About Patrick Mahomes’ Injury

Patrick Mahomes injury theories follow his return.

Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes suffered a devastating knee injury that prematurely ended his 2025 NFL season.

Initially, the catastrophic incident occurred during the fourth quarter of a Week 15 matchup against the Los Angeles Chargers. Mahomes scrambled completely out of the pocket, delivered a deep throw, and instantly felt his left knee buckle.

Consequently, medical scans quickly revealed that the star quarterback had severely torn both his ACL and LCL. The brutal dual-ligament tear marked the single most significant physical injury of his nine-year professional football career.

Specifically, the sudden injury mathematically eliminated the struggling Chiefs from the postseason while forcing Mahomes straight into surgery.

Patrick Mahomes immediately flew out to Dallas to undergo a complex surgical procedure performed by Dr. Dan Cooper.

A familiar argument about Patrick Mahomes has been circulating after an account asked whether the December knee injury was staged for storyline purposes. In the post, the timing is treated as the evidence: the tear arrived as Kansas City was eliminated from the playoffs. The same thread then asks if the Week 1 return is supposed to close that loop.

Here is how social media reacted:

“How many of you think Patrick Mahomes knee injury was fake for storyline purposes? Or did he really coincidentally hurt it just as the chiefs were eliminated from the playoffs?” a post asked.

“he had surgery like 2 days later, it’s total bull sh-t,” a fan said.

Fake.. couldn’t have Mahomes under center for a team that was eliminated from the playoffs. The super quick recovery time, too. Now he’s just perfectly fine. Chiefs will bounce back this season,” a second person stated.

“It was totally fake. Compare his rehab to Daniel Jones. Both had the same injury around the same time and Jones rehab took longer. Mahomes faked it so he could avoid taking the blame for the Chiefs poor season,” a third person wrote.

“I think he hurt it but not near as bad as they said it was,” a fourth person commented.

Moving forward, Kansas City hosts the rival Denver Broncos at Arrowhead Stadium to close out Week 1. Specifically, this prime-time division clash officially marks the start of Mahomes’ tenth season leading the franchise.

Fortunately, Mahomes attacked his extensive rehabilitation timeline with an incredibly intense, non-stop daily training work ethic. Moving forward, his remarkably fast nine-month recovery allowed him to be fully cleared for the 2026 season opener.

However, there are now questions about his quick recovery.